Want more of Bwana? Check out my video podcast
 

Do The Florida Gators Deserve To Play For The BCS Championship?

In: football

6 Dec 2008
University of Florida quarterback Tim Tebow (R) runs for first ... - Yahoo! News Photos
Photo courtesy of Reuters

Tonight, the Florida Gators handed the Alabama Crimson Tide their first loss of the season. This college football game was one of the best SEC championship games in recent history. Florida and Alabama traded leads throughout the game and the momentum shifted so much, it was hard to tell who would pull it out.

The scoring breakdown shows it was a story of quarters:

Gators Beat Alabama

Alabama took the first and third quarters, while Florida owned the second and fourth quarters. In the end, Florida stepped up when it mattered. I was on Twitter (via my iPhone) expressing my thoughts, and tweeted this when Florida was down 20 – 17 at the end of the third quarter:

photo.jpg - Bwana.org Mail

As it turns out, the Gators scored that drive and held Alabama to 0 points in the 4th quarter. An impressive win to say the least, but is it enough? Is this win enough to propel the 4th ranked Florida Gators above the 3rd ranked Texas to play for the BCS National Title? As a Florida Gator fan, of course I believe the Gators are a better team than anyone in the country, so let’s just get that out there right now. Texas is a great team, Oklahoma is a great time, heck, Penn State and USC are great teams and no one is really talking about it?

It’s hard to say which is the better team without playing it on the field. Fortunately, Oklahoma and Texas have already settled the dispute, so if Oklahoma wins tonight, they should definitely be in. But, it’s not clear that Florida should jump two spots for beating the #1 team in the nation by 11 points in the conference championship. The only way to make this clear is to implement a playoff system. Keep the BCS, but put the top 4 teams in a playoff system to play during December when teams are usually off. Please. This is only definitive way to answer this question.

With the current system however, I believe the Florida Gators should be in the BCS title game. Is it fair? Of course not. It’s not fair to Penn State, USC, Texas, and all the other 1 loss teams who feel they should be playing for it all. (including Alabama) I’ll be watching the Oklahoma/Missouri game closely and if Missou wins, it’s going to be interesting to see who plays against Florida in the title game. We’ll see.

The next obvious question is, should Tim Tebow be seriously considered as a Heisman trophy repeat? Hmmmmmmmm :)

Related posts:

View Comments to Do The Florida Gators Deserve To Play For The BCS Championship?

Avatar

Bwana (Bwana)

December 6th, 2008 at 6:17 pm

New blog post: Do The Florida Gators Deserve To Play For The BCS Championship? http://tinyurl.com/6gwz5a

Avatar

Bwana (Bwana)

December 6th, 2008 at 6:17 pm

New blog post: Do The Florida Gators Deserve To Play For The BCS Championship? http://tinyurl.com/6gwz5a

Avatar

Kay (KI2594)

December 7th, 2008 at 2:24 am

i believe they should jump in at 2nd and play for the BCS against Oklahoma who looks pretty good right now against Mizzou.

I really want to watch Bradford vs. Tebow :)

Avatar

Bwana

December 7th, 2008 at 2:33 am

Yeah and it'll be a great coming home for Bob Stoops who was Florida's defensive coordinator on their 1996 national title team under Spurrier.

Avatar

Eric Doerr

December 7th, 2008 at 2:42 am

It should be them and SC. I am biased for Southern Cal, but they are the two best all-around teams. What makes me mad is the inconsistency with all of this. UF lost to Ole Miss at home (by 1), but that is no big deal to voters. SC lost to Oregon State on the road (ranked in the top 25 for half of the year) and all we hear is how USC can't handle the heat. Why? I don't know. There's just no consistency with the voters because a loss at home to bad team > than a loss on the road to a future top 25 team. It's basically everything that the voters are against….but not this year. Florida is in the SEC which is way sexier to voters than USC with the PAC-10 even though the SEC is down big time this year. All this talk has a solution: playoffs. OU runs up the score so they look better in the computers. UT beat them on a neutral field and are sitting at home tonight. Of course I'm going to complain about a playoff system being from Southern Cal :) , but no doubt the Tebows should be playing for a Championship in the current system. No questions about it. Tonight will be interesting because we don't even know where Bama will end up. But if we had a playoff system? There wouldn't be any questions. Maybe about who gets in to the final spot or not, but that's only 2-3 teams that would have a case rather than 6+ in the current system. Let's the kids decide it on the field where no one has to run up the score or do anything out of the ordinary to make their case.

I'd vote Tebow for Heisman. Sam Bradford is THE BEST QB in the nation right now, but his stats are so padded with the way Stoops calls plays up until the very end. Hell he went for it up 4th and goal up 62-14 a few weeks ago. Colt McCoy is a little better all around with his running ability than Bradford, but it's hard to vote for him looking at his teams current situation (he got screwed). You have to be consistent with the voting and they usually don't reward players who's teams aren't in the National Championship unless they are a complete standout. Graham Harrell is in a system and is the very best at running that system he is in, but I don't think he has a chance anymore. That leaves Tebow: I'd vote for him based on his speech after the Ole Miss game, but UF would be 8-4 at best without him. He's playing better than he did last year.

If they vote UF in, I'll be rooting for your Gators (unless they miraculously vote in the Trojans, but the AP and Computers don't like them). They are everything the SEC is not: spread offense and excitement (and defense which is nonexistent in the Big 12). Chomp away; I'll be smelling the Roses.

Avatar

Bwana

December 7th, 2008 at 2:48 am

Wow, great comment. Thanks for your insight. I believe USC is better than what the polls indicate as well. The system is such a mess and you're absolutely right about a playoff system solving it all.

Avatar

Bwana

December 7th, 2008 at 3:34 am

I saw your post that the Bears won easily so I'm happy for you in that regard. I understand your disdain for USC as I can't stand the Miami Hurricanes nor the Florida State Seminoles. In state rivalries tend to bring that out :)

Avatar

Matt Bebich

December 7th, 2008 at 3:49 am

I think Texas should be in the championship game with Oklahoma. USC should drop in rankings because they are not that good. My team UCLA held them to 24 points which is good considering how much injuries UCLA has got. Florida should be number 3

Avatar

Louis Gray

December 7th, 2008 at 4:37 am

I suggest it should be Florida and Oklahoma. The way the system is set up now, you don't just reward overall records, but you reward the momentum and the amount of pummeling they deliver opponents. Oklahoma is crazy good, and Florida has risen up at the right time.

(Disclosure: Cal alum… likes Da Bears… who are headed to the weak Emerald Bowl. This of course means I hate $C.)

Avatar

Bwana

December 7th, 2008 at 1:50 pm

This is a test comment to test Facebook connect. Please ignore.

Avatar

Florida BCS Tickets

December 7th, 2008 at 6:13 pm

I was surprised by Florida and Tebow. He is the man, but I guess I had not learned that yet. I think that it HAS to be Florida and Oklahoma because right now the SEC has proven that over the past years they are better than all the other conferences, so until someone can prove otherwise, the SEC champion has to be considered the top dog.

Avatar

Chris

December 7th, 2008 at 7:01 pm

any team that wins the SEC should be in the BCS championship game

Avatar

jaxdotcom (jaxdotcom)

December 9th, 2008 at 7:24 am

Do The Florida Gators Deserve To Play For The BCS Championship? (via Bwana.org) http://tinyurl.com/6gwz5a

Avatar

jaxdotcom (jaxdotcom)

December 9th, 2008 at 7:24 am

Do The Florida Gators Deserve To Play For The BCS Championship? (via Bwana.org) http://tinyurl.com/6gwz5a

Avatar

DrJz

December 9th, 2008 at 12:12 pm

The FL-AL game was the second best this year, after Texas-Texas Tech. IMHO: Texas should be in the NC game because they have several top wins and only 1 very tough loss (and I don’t like Texas). McCoy nearly brought them all the way back, on the road against a fresh and very charged Texas Tech team. FL is probably the best choice against TX in the NC game. OK looked great against MO but very bad against TX on a neutral field. USC has played a weak schedule but at least you could be sure they would ‘show up’ in the NC game (and I don’t like USC!), unlike OK in some instances. FL-OK may be interesting whereas FL-TX would almost certainly be classic.

Tebow is clearly the MVP (and I don’t like FL either!) though McCoy has done very well and deserves consideration. [Obligatory if irrelevant: 'Go Irish']

Avatar

Woods Recruiting » Florida and Alabama College Football

October 19th, 2009 at 2:36 pm

[...] Florida and Alabama are the top two teams in the first BCS standings of the season. Florida and Alabama right now are clearly the two best college football teams but will they remain undefeated? Will they go all the way and play for a national championship?  The national championship, as we all know, is not determined in a playoff system but based on the Bowl championship series standings. Florida and Alabama are the best teams in college football. [...]

Comment Form

blog comments powered by Disqus

About Bwana

  • Host of Bwana.org Radio & Bwana.TV. Gamer, movie lover, faithful husband, and certifiably crazy. He is all over the internets if you look closely

    Google Instant is all kinds of cool. Search results as you type. And it's FAST! http://www.google.com/instant 13 hrs ago

Social



Powered by Rackspace Cloud Hosting - Formerly Mosso
Powered by Rackspace Cloud Hosting