Gaming, Technology, Social Media, and Fun
In: geek
2 Jul 2008One of the conversations that stemmed from our “Twit-Out” a few months ago was, “Can we save Twitter with open-source?” My response was the following:
I agree that Twitter could use some help, but I don’t know if opening the source is the main solution. I do believe, a healthy dose of stiff competition encourages innovation. [...]
Today, I joined Identi.ca. Is it YATC (Yet another Twitter clone)? Sure seems like it on the surface. Identi.ca offers a timeline view identical to Twitter, limits your updates to 140 characters, and it offers Jabber/Gtalk posts and updates. If that ain’t a Twitter clone, I don’t know what is. Here’s what the founding company, Control Yourself ,has to say:
Identi.ca is similar to existing microblogging sites such as Twitter, Jaiku, or Pownce. Unlike those services, Identi.ca’s underlying software is available under an Open Source license. Identi.ca is also the first service to support OpenMicroBlogging, a standard for exchanging short messages between microblogging sites. Identi.ca also makes public user data available under a Creative Commons license in standard formats.
That’s a great quote because it clearly outlines a huge differentiator from Twitter: Identi.ca is open sourced. I stand by my original assessment that it’s not clear whether an open sourced Twitter will actually be a better Twitter, but I will watch it very closely. Another point that should be noted about Identi.ca, is that it supports OpenMicroBlogging. The software that runs Identi.ca, called Laconi.ca, allows users to run their own federated instance of the software. This has made advocates of a federated Twitter, like Dave Winer, very excited about the possibilities. I have went on record to say that a federated architecture is not also guaranteed to produce a successful Twitter, as there have been many stable non-federated messaging systems. They all had a sound design. I’m not saying it won’t work, I’m stating that it’s not a silver bullet. Either way, it’s happening now that Identi.ca has entered the space. With juggernauts such as Winer “excited” about it, it can only be a good thing for developer momentum.
So what are my thoughts about Identi.ca so far? My day 0 impressions are:
According to their FAQ, many of my gripes are “coming soon”. Given the age of this service, I cannot declare it a success or failure just yet. If anyone else does, I will greatly question their motives. I do think that the addition of open source and a possible federated Twitter make it a service to watch in the coming months.
Twitter, it’s time to get stable right now.
Related posts:
Google Instant is all kinds of cool. Search results as you type. And it's FAST! http://www.google.com/instant 14 hrs ago

View Comments to An Open Sourced Twitter Emerges: Identi.ca
Could Identi.ca be a Fail Whale Killer?
July 2nd, 2008 at 6:48 pm
[...] Bwana points out in a post that Indenti.ca is fairly feature poor so far, and the service lacks basics such as an API. There is a long list of “soon” features here, the bigger question though is how quickly some of the key features can be rolled out to keep people using the service? [...]
Apture makes killer plug-in for web sites and blogs — Julians.name
July 2nd, 2008 at 9:00 pm
[...] evening I found a link to an interesting blog post. Not only did I enjoy learning about the new open source Twitter client called identi.ca from my Plurk friend Bwana, I also couldn’t help but notice his very useful site plug-in that [...]
Identi.ca: Twitter Alternative » Webomatica - Technology and Entertainment Digest
July 3rd, 2008 at 1:30 am
[...] Additional Reading: Scripting News, Bwana.org [...]
Identi.ca, Not Perfect, But Good Enough « Web 0.2
July 3rd, 2008 at 2:21 pm
[...] http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/indentica_federated_twitter.php http://www.bwana.org/2008/07/02/an-open-sourced-twitter-emerges-identica/ Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Pushing the release?Press Release Me, Let Me Go… [...]
Evan Prodromou
January 10th, 2009 at 6:05 am
Hi, Bwana! Thanks a ton for your contributions on Identi.ca today, and for this helpful list of priority tasks. I'm working hard right now to get the performance up to snuff, but next on my list is low-hanging fruit like replies, search, and SMS. Never you fear — the Open Source model is *awesome* for developing features like this.
bwana18751
January 10th, 2009 at 6:05 am
No problem Evan. I'll be keeping a close eye on your progress.
Derrick
January 10th, 2009 at 6:05 am
You can scratch SEARCH off of the "wants" list, it is there now.
JimQ
January 10th, 2009 at 6:05 am
Can you believe all the players in this space now? Seems like a new one every quarter. Do you feel like these new kids in town are legit competitors to Twitter?
BTW, really enjoy your videos!